Joint Action Committee on CYBERCRIME Bill 2015

Cyber Crime Bill 2015[15 April 2015]

The Press Conference was addressed by Wahaj us Siraj, Convener, Internet Service Providers Association of Pakistan (ISPAK), Farieha Aziz, Director, Bolo Bhi, Syed Ahmad, Spokesman, Pakistan Software Houses Association, Asif Luqman Qazi, Executive Director, Center for Discussions and Solutions (CDS), Khawaja Saad Saleem, Vice President ISPAK and others.
The Government of Pakistan has submitted the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Bill (PECB) 2015 in Parliament, which is currently believed to be before the NA Standing Committee on IT. The proceedings of NA Standing Committee are being kept under secrecy, making it non-transparent and non-consultative. A copy of Bill has been obtained which is at

The draft Bill in its current form will seriously impact the Internet users, ICT industry, print and electronic media, academicians, researchers, the legal community and ordinary citizens particularly educated youth of Pakistan.

A few glaring highlights of the Bill that would seriously effect civil liberties are as follows:

  1. In Sections 17 and 18, political criticism and political expression in the form of analysis, commentary, blogs and cartoons, caricatures, memes, etc., has been criminalized.
  2. Obscene or immoral messages on Facebook, twitter, etc., have been made offenses as per Section 20, without defining obscenity or immorality, thus giving sweeping powers to investigating agencies to implicate anyone on these charges.
  3. As per Section 19, any person who tests system security will be an offender;
  4. Sending an email or message without the recipient’s permission will become an offence as per Section 21;
  5. As per Section 20, posting of photograph of any person on Facebook or Instagram without their permission is an offence.
  6. Section 31 gives the government/PTA unfettered powers to block access or remove speech not only on the Internet but transmitted through any device, limiting the media’s freedom and citizens’ right to expression;
  7. In Section 26, the definition of service providers – traditionally ISPs and telcos – has been expanded to now include any place that offers access to the Internet to the public, i.e., restaurants, malls, hotels, offices, airports, stations and the additional burden of retaining traffic data has been placed on them – and they can be punished for not doing so.

Fundamental principles of law, such as requiring intent, especially malicious intent to be established for conviction, have not been followed – in fact the requirement has been omitted from the modified version of this Bill. This is true even for offences such as Cyber Terrorism, which carries a penalty of fourteen years imprisonment. There is a grave danger of white-hat hackers, hobbyists, people who hack for academic purposes to identify security flaws in systems, or teenagers who for recreation (albeit wrongly) deface websites, could end up getting convicted as cyber terrorists.

Checks and balances on investigation agencies and officers have been removed. For example, requiring an investigation officer to obtain a warrant from court for search, seizure or arrest on the basis of a list of qualifications he/she was required to present before court, making clear reasons why the warrant should be issued, no longer exists. Similarly, other safeguards that were previously built in, such as protection against self-incrimination and an accused’s right to know the charges against him/her, have also been omitted.

The above provisions of the draft Bill in particular, and several others in general, violate fundamental rights of expression, freedom of media and due process as enshrined in the 1973 Constitution. In its current form, the draft Bill will not counter crime or terrorism; on the contrary it will lockdown the society, industry and the media; and will criminalize innocent citizens.

We, Pakistan Software House Association (PASHA), Internet Service Providers Association of Pakistan (ISPAK), BoloBhi, Civil Society, Students and Professionals, therefore demand that
• the draft bill be made public;
• public and independent expert input be sought and incorporated before the Standing Committee finalizes its debate.

The alarm bells have been sounded. Time for you to do your bit. Don’t take this lightly!

Sign this e-petition asking legislators to make the bill public and seek public input here

Cyber Crime Bill 2015-2

Source : Joint Action Committee on CYBERCRIME Press Release.


One thought on “Joint Action Committee on CYBERCRIME Bill 2015

  1. A bunch of (not so) secret establishment , slowly applying compartmentalization on a sleeping public, who are already fucked by the humongous yet still getting BIGGER DICK of TAXES. But hey who cares as long as they can get Big Tits to suck on, as long as there is “CONNECTIVITY”, and ‘Fa/uc/k Book’ to “Be Social”. Sheeple wasting time on things that don’t even matter! Ya great! we have the illusion of choices, we’ll elect another party next time, PTI’ll win?? Like that would change a thing! As long as we have dumb public, we’ll have the exact politicians. Poor Politicians, people curse them and still vote them all the same, ya , like staying at home on voting day can save us from the corrupts, when our vote isn’t already automatically cast for the ruling party!!!!!!

Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s